Earl is the man who owns the Red Apple restuarant in Pegasus and the Fight for Olympus. After finding smoke in the abandonned restuarant and finding a girl (Emily Jacobs) opening the door, he accidentally pulls the trigger on his gun and shoots Emily in the chest. Earl stays with Emily and Pegasus to wait for their friends, Paelen, Joel DeSilva and Cupid, along with Agent T, to return with Emily's father Steve.

However, Nirads soon attack their hiding area and Earl is buried in the burning reckage after Emily uncontrollably sets the roof on fire. Earl is later saved by Paelen, Cupid, and Agent T. In the end, he lives with Frankie, a boy in Pegasus and the New Olympians.